Bruce Springsteen covers Seeger, and the energetic results are nothing to protest.
by David Browne in Entertainment Weekly
Given all the protest songs in Seeger's songbook -- and given Springsteen's blunt criticisms of the current administration -- We Shall Overcome is surprisingly light on politics; none of Seeger's songs about civil rights incidents or labor unions are here. Only "Mrs. McGrath," about a soldier who returns from combat with two leg pegs, makes the most overt reference to modern times. (To ensure we get the connection, Springsteen changes the original's "King of France" to "King of America.") Springsteen is more interested in plumbing Americana folklore legends, and the plan works. With its strapping versions of "John Henry" and "Jesse James," the album taps back into what Springsteen does best: making music that's as grand and mythopoetic as the country itself.
Sometimes he and his musicians -- a big, unwieldy combo with no E Streeters save for wife Patti Scialfa -- seem a little too excited and end up riding roughshod over songs that Seeger performed with charming simplicity. But we all know what happens when Springsteen pares things down dramatically (can you hum even one song from Joad or Devils & Dust?), so let's not complain too much. We Shall Overcome lets us revel in the sound of a man who no longer confuses unplugged with uninspiring -- and who isn't afraid to mix in some merriment with the message. A-
Springsteen salutes Pete Seeger with a joyful noise.
by Jonathan Ringen in Rolling Stone
Springsteen has always mined a deep vein of Americana, from the hot-rod-and-B-movie obsessed early albums to the Steinbeckian social realism of The Ghost of Tom Joad and last year's Devils and Dust. But with his first-ever album of songs written by other people, it feels like he's turned to the music of our shared past to find a moral compass for a nation that's gone off the rails. The protest anthems "Eyes on the Prize" and "We Shall Overcome" are performed with an understated urgency: the gospel standard "Oh, Mary, Don't You Weep" -- which Springsteen sings in a gruff Tom Waits-ish baritone and to which the Seeger Sessions Band gives a Dixieland treatment with Stéphane Grappelli-style violin -- promises, "Brothers and sisters, don't you cry/ There'll be good times by and by."
Springsteen discovered most of these tunes -- which also include sea chanteys ("Pay Me My Money Down"), minstrel songs ("Old Dan Tucker") and outlaw ballads ("Jessie James") -- on LPs by Seeger. Among the pleasures of this album is rediscovering childhood staples like "Erie Canal" or "John Henry" via Springsteen's craggy, familiar voice -- which is as mighty and powerful as the steel-driving man himself. * * * *
by Dan Snierson in Entertainment Weekly
Oates, you answer this question as if you were Hall, and Hall, you answer this question as if you were Oates. How's it going?
JO It's going just swimmingly.
DH Would I say "swimmingly," though?
JO No, probably not.
My brain just melted -- go back to being yourselves. You recently appeared on Will & Grace, playing "Maneater" at Grace's wedding. Which was harder -- playing "Maneater" or playing yourselves playing "Maneater"?
DH We were always playing ourselves playing "Maneater."
JO Oooh, very Zen, Hall... Zen Hall? Isn't that, like, a gym at a really bad community college?
What's the most rock 'n soul thing you've done today?
DH Let's see... I ordered a pair of cowboy boots from a guy in Commanche, Texas.
JO Honestly, I have not done anything rock 'n soul today... I fed the llamas. I don't know if that's rock 'n soul, but --
DH I think that's pretty soulful.
JO There you go. Fed the llamas.
You employ the catchy gimmick of spelling "M-E-T-H-O-D-O-F-L-O-V-E" in "Method of Modern Love." Have you ever played that song in concert and mistakenly misspelled those words, and if so, was it V-E-R-Y-A-W-K-W-A-R-D?
DH When you sing, you don't blow it. If I were asked to spell it normally, I might make a mistake.
Care to weigh in, Oates?
JO No... I can spell.
Do you guys split the groupies 50-50, or is it every half of Hall & Oates for himself?
DH Well, we're a little beyond splitting of groupies... I get 'em all, actually. John is married with a child. He's relinquished his groupie card.
JO My groupie grope is gone.
Oates, you shaved off your mustache. Did you need multiple government agencies to sign off on that?
JO No, but it was a psychically freeing moment. I'm sure it didn't mean anything to anyone else, but it was very important to me.
DH Actually, I would disagree. I think it meant a lot to a lot of people... [Conversation about mustaches continues for a while] A mustache means some strange thing. I don't know what it is.
The two of you met in an elevator while fleeing a gang fight at a dance. That sounds a little wimpy. Let's come up with a better story.
DH We never existed because we were killed in a gang fight.
JO Oh, God. What would the world do?
DH All those songs would be lost to history.
JO An alternative universe without "Maneater" would be a hollow place.
On the album cover of Rock 'n Soul Part 1, you guys seem to be engaged in an awesome arm-wrestling match. Between us, who won that match -- or do we have to wait for Rock 'n Soul Part 2 to find out?
DH Well, John has bigger muscles but I have longer arms.
JO It was leverage against power.
DH Archimedes would have the answer to this.
JO This is a physics problem, not a rock 'n soul problem.
Best of EXTRA! | EXTRA! | Main Page | Seventies Single Spotlight | Search The RockSite/The Web